As we reported here earlier, Ilya Kovalchuk is now a member of the New Jersey Devils. This sets into motion a series of compelling storylines and, suitably, closes a pile of other storylines.
Working on what we know, Kovalchuk wanted out of Atlanta. The first overall selection in the 2001 NHL entry draft had no interest in remaining a Thrasher and had no interest in investing any more of himself to the city of Atlanta than was necessary. While he never came right out and demanded a trade, there was no question that Kovy wanted out.
A player who wants to remain with a team typically doesn’t turn down two lucrative deals to stay there, as Kovy did with Don Waddell’s obscene pair of offers last fall. Even after rejecting those deals, Waddell wanted to keep his superstar. That’s why he peppered up a deal worth another pile of money to keep his player. The deal, had Kovalchuk signed, would have made the Thrasher the highest paid player in the National Hockey League.
With battles in the management in Atlanta and inconsistency on the ice, Kovalchuk’s desire to leave could hardly be blamed. In looking at the Thrashers, he saw what the rest of us see on a nightly basis: a team going nowhere. His dedication to the squad was nonexistent, so Waddell’s desire to keep such a player really brings up a few questions.
Why take such a risk? Why pay a player so much money if it’s clear he doesn’t want to play there?
That, it seems, is where the Devils came in. Obviously looking for a roster shuffle of their own, New Jersey has gone on a disappointing slide as of late and have had to contend with the loss of Patrik Elias. It’s not an easy picture in Jersey, so Lou Lamoriello knew something had to be done. With the Kovalchuk sweepstakes heating up, it was time to make something happen.
Lamoriello gave up Swedish defenceman Johnny Oduya, rookie forward Niclas Bergfors, prospect Patrick Cormier, and a first-round pick for Kovalchuk and defenceman Anssi Salmela.
So who wins?
Kovalchuk is obviously an impact player, but how well he’ll mesh with Jersey’s style remains to be seen. Indeed, the style question is probably the biggest question mark regarding this whole convoluted matter. Considering how desperate the Devils were for a roster repositioning, it may be possible that they’re also desperate to try new things on the ice too. But is now the time for experimentation? Is now the time to shift things up ice from a defensive-minded perspective to a run-and-gun style?
This alteration in style would make sense if it appeared that Kovalchuk was more than just a rental, but few signs point to his desire to sign a long-term deal in New Jersey. The most likely option at this point remains that he’ll bolt for the KHL, so it’s hard to imagine the logic behind Lamoriello and Co. shifting things so drastically for a muted playoff run.
In the end, Atlanta comes out looking okay. Oduya is a capable defenceman who can crunch some minutes. Bergfors may turn out to be an unsung hero sort of player and Cormier’s reputation proceeds him.
The situation mirrors the one from two years ago when the Thrashers were “forced” to give up Marian Hossa for a pile of similar players. In the long run, deals like this may lead to an inevitable and much-needed reshuffling of management in Atlanta. Of course, the ownership has to have a reasonable interest in seeing on-ice success for that sort of thing to happen.
Posted by Jordan Richardson.
